Home » History, North America, Politics » UN: America must give Mount Rushmore to Native Americans

UN: America must give Mount Rushmore to Native Americans

submit to reddit

History: A Sioux man stands in front of the Mount Rushmore National Memorial - control of which a UN investigator has recommended the U.S. turn over

A UN human rights official is urging the U.S. to turn over control of lands considered to be sacred to Native Americans, including the site of the Mount Rushmore National Memorial.

James Anaya, the UN special rapporteur on the rights of indigenous peoples, unveiled his recommendations in Geneva on Friday after completing a 12-day visit to the U.S. where he met with representatives of indigenous peoples in six states.

The fact-finder also had a chance to meet members of the Obama administration and briefed the U.S. Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, but no member of Congress agreed to meet with him.

‘I have heard stories that make evident the profound hurt that indigenous peoples continue to feel because of the history of oppression they have faced,’ Mr Anaya said in a statement.

For over a century, he said, the government had seized lands and resources from Native Americans, removed children from their families and communities, caused the loss of languages, broke treaties with tribes and oppressed the indigenous peoples on the grounds of racial discrimination.

‘The sense of loss, alienation and indignity is pervasive throughout Indian Country,’ Mr Anaya said.

He welcomed the U.S. decision to endorse the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples in 2010, reversing a previous vote, but said that more must be done.

Mr Anaya’s findings will be included in a final report submitted to the UN Human Rights Council. While not binding, the recommendations carry moral weight that can influence governments.

In Alaska and the Pacific Northwest, where some indigenous tribes depend on hunting and fishing, Mr Anaya said residents face ‘ever-greater threats… due to a growing surge of competing interests, and in some cases incompatible extractive activities, over these lands and resources.’

Laxly regulated mining for natural resources, including uranium, in some parts of the country has also caused serious health problems among indigenous peoples, who are suffering the after effects of water contamination.

The UN expert visited an Oglala Sioux reservation where the per capita income hovers around $7,000 a year, less than one sixth of the national average, and life expectancy stands at about 50 years, according to the Guardian.

He also said indigenous peoples feel they have too little control over geographic regions considered sacred to them, like the San Francisco Peaks in Arizona and the Black Hills in South Dakota. Mr Anaya suggested such lands should be returned to native peoples.

Mount Rushmore, a popular tourist attraction, is located in the Black Hills, which the Sioux tribes consider to be sacred and have territorial claims to based on an 1868 treaty.

Shortly after that treaty was signed, gold was discovered in the region, and the U.S. Congress eventually passed a law taking over the land.

‘I’m talking about restoring to indigenous peoples what obviously they’re entitled to and they have a legitimate claim to in a way that is not divisive but restorative,’ Mr Anaya said.

In 1980, the Supreme Court ruled that the land was seized illegally and ordered the government to pay compensation. The Sioux, however, rejected the money, calling for the return of the now public lands.

Mr Anaya said he will make specific recommendations on these and other issues in a full report to be released in September.

Last month, the U.S. Justice Department announced that the government had agreed to pay more than $1billion to 40 Native American tribes to settle lawsuits over the use of tribal lands held in trust by the federal government, but exploited by private companies for timber, mining and farming.

The U.S. is home to some two million Native Americans, nearly half of them living on 310 reservations. While some tribes have prospered thanks to the booming gambling business, others are trailing national averages in income and health.


VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 5.0/5 (1 vote cast)
UN: America must give Mount Rushmore to Native Americans, 5.0 out of 5 based on 1 rating


Did you like this information? Then please consider making a donation or subscribing to our Newsletter.
  • Alfred F. Jones

    Ok then Israel must give back all lands back to the Palastinians and give back all money given to them by the American goverment back to the Americans.

    • Selab Kram

      The ‘NATIVE’ Americans weren’t really native after all, they immigrated over the Bearing Sea land bridge during the last Ice Age. Think Kennewick man, Solutraeans.

  • Al

    Alfred, an error does not justify the other. Is typical of your warmongering culture think like that. You killed all the native americans and stealed their lands, as you’re doing in the middle east. But who cares…time will punish USA.

    • Alfred F. Jones

      Um….Not to dissapoint but my ancestors were sold by their own people to Americans and worked in their fields 0-0

    • sky

      How are the natives in Brazil doing? You know, the ones that the Brazilians are currently murdering….

  • Bonsai Guy

    Cease their menacing claims.

  • Randomguy

    Wow, you Americans can’t still see that what you did to the Native Americans was on bar with the nazis. Only difference is: nazis were stopped, you are still at it.

    • Alfred F. Jones

      I am not a warmonger and My ancestors were sold by their own people to Americans to work for them

    • sky

      On par with the Nazis? Were the Jews murdering women and children and taking their scalps? The Native Americans were… Were the Jews kidnapping and ransoming colonists? The Native Americans were…. Last time I checked a history book, most Native Americans died from natural causes (diseases:i.e. smallpox,flu). Did the Nazis kill most of the Jews with naturally occurring diseases? Are you aware that many tribes fought with the Americans to kill their neighboring tribes. Which tribes would the ‘repatriated’ land go to?

    • sky

      Furthermore, “Randomguy”, shall we review Estonia’s history of Nazis sympathizing(which included active participation in the holocaust)?

      • Randomguy

        You came to their land and took it as your own killed who stood in your way, and the Native Americans are the bad guy because they tried to fight for what was theirs…wow the nerve on them.

        Nazi sympathizing? Please. You mean the time when we were occupied by German and the military draft was mandatory?
        And if honoring our fallen men is sympathizing, then yes we are sympathizers.

    • PersonGuy

      A number Native American Indians I have met sympathize with Nazism. I don’t really know why. Maybe simple ignorance in the west. Maybe you get cause and consequence confused.

  • Freja’s Lover

    So that’s why the United Snakes is sympathetic to Israel’s permanent occupation and further acquisition of Palestine. If they protest to Israel they will come under scrutiny themselves to return land to its rightful, Indian owners.

Copyright © 2009 The European Union Times – Breaking News, Latest News. All rights reserved.